Voting closed last September 14, 2016, and were conducted for the readers of Newtype Magazine.
Makoto Shinkai (your name.) There you have it, the winners of the Newtype Awards, with Kabaneri, your name., and Re:Zero predictably winning major spots on top of several of the various categories.
To be eligible to win the award, the works must be aired or screened between the periods of October 2015 and July 2016, so older works are not included.
Previously, Macross Delta was leading in the preliminary results for the TV anime, while Girls und Panzer der Film was in the lead for the anime movie.